XD As soon as I heard this I had to burst out laughing, it even beats out Guitar Hero 2, Legend of Zelda:TP (considered by pretty much everyone else as the Game of the year) Gears of War, Bully, and many other titles.
#1 Game of the year according to Time Magazine. . .prepare to be shocked
I'd argue, but I play it often enough that it would seem hypocritical.
Doesn't seem right, though.